| BUILDING NEW
PRISONS FOR DRUG CRIMES LIKE BUILDING CEMETERIES FOR CANCER,
JUDGE SAYS
All day conference brings
together diverse fields in look at youth in trouble.
"I made a mistake," Brenda
Olive stated. "I made a wrong choice, I know. I tried to
sell drugs to make money." She paused to wipe tears from her
cheeks. "I was not a drug user. Most people think that
people who go to prison are bad people. I'm one of those
people they call bad people."
Speaking to an audience of
over eighty people, Ms. Olive related her story as part of a
day long conference sponsored by the Drug Policy Education
Group, Inc. Featuring a host of speakers who addressed a
wide variety of topics related to at-risk youth in the
state, "Arkansas Youth in Trouble: What Works, What's
Needed, and Where's the Money?" brought together school
counselors, social workers, educators, medical
professionals, and youth advocates for interactive sessions
all day Saturday November 18 at the Riverfront Hilton in
North Little Rock.
"I always thought families
were something that happened," Brenda Olive continued. "I
never found one of those. I've been on a journey, looking
for family. I was given away at two months to a lady who was
very abusive. I married, had children, divorced and
remarried and had another set of children. With the second
set of children, my husband was an alcoholic and became very
ill. A few months after became ill, I found out my nine year
old child had cancer.
"So I went along on this
journey, looking for family. In 1982 they told me there was
nothing else they could do for either one. I took a leave of
absence from my job and took care of my daughter at home. My
husband died and my daughter died a month later. I was about
to lose the house and everything was sold.
"I made a wrong choice. I
sold some drugs and went to prison. I was there seven
months... I had a 17-year-old who went to Central. She stood
in for me. Six years later, after we were in counseling, I
found out what had happened while I was gone. One had been
sexually abused. One had had an abortion. One had been
beaten. All this came out when I was already feeling bad
that I had made wrong choices.
"So what do I do? I tried
apologizing, I tried everything, still my son continued to
get into trouble. I feel like he was seeking some kind of
help which at that time I didn't understand. The journey
continued. Now I'm raising one of his children. He's
incarcerated.
"I feel like there is a
breakdown in the system -- when you've been to prison, when
you've been what society calls a bad person, you can't work
-- Right now, I have not made wrong choices. I became
disabled. I've lost another house. But this time, I've just
lost.
"I've had people call me
who've been free and had no crime since the 70s, and a
background check is done and they lose their job. I think
there should be some type of cut off point that if you get
out of prison and stay crime free five to ten years,
something should be done when you have proved yourself.
"Where society has bad people
right now is, you can't get work, you can't get welfare, you
can't get housing. What do we do?"
Citing Arkansas' welfare
reform as one of the harshest in the nation, the following
speaker, Dee Ann Newell, commented on the "outrageous"
treatment of the state's disenfranchised populations.
"Two million people
incarcerated in this country, making us history's greatest
jailer ever for mankind... In 1991 when we started our
prison programs through the Centers (the Centers for
Families and Children), we had about 200 women in the Pine
Bluff unit. Then in 1994, they moved the women to Tucker
because there were too many, over 400. In 1998, we moved the
women to Newport, to the first for-profit prison in our
state. And there are 685 beds at that unit. Then there are
another 250 women backed up in our jails waiting for
openings at the prison.
Ms. Newell makes weekly
visits to three prisons in the state, working under a
Rockefeller grant which supports her work with incarcerated
parents and their children. She stated that part of the
problem is the failed war on drugs.
"Eighty percent of all women
in prison are mothers of minor children. In the state of
Arkansas, the average age of these children is six years.
The average age of the mothers is 29. Seventy percent of
women in prison are there on either direct drug charges or
drug related crimes like hot checks," Newell said.
"We stiffened the penalties
for these crimes so much that some of these women are
serving an average of 49 months. Right now there's a woman
-- first time offender -- hot check charge -- and she got
five years.
"In the name of the public,
we have harshened these sentences. At the same time, the
public is going to pay. It costs money to house people in
prison, but beyond that there is a hidden cost, which is the
cost these children are paying.
"The children of incarcerated
parents -- these are the children who are most vulnerable to
get into trouble, to go to prison -- they carry a five times
greater risk factor than all other groups of children.
"When we look at incarcerated
women, we see women who are disproportionately women of
color, women of poverty with an average household income of
less than $500. We see women of addiction. These are women
of low educational attainment. Most of these women report a
childhood history of sexual and physical abuse, and an adult
history of being a victim of domestic violence."
Ms. Newell's comments ended
with a call to action for citizens and legislators to impose
a moratorium on new prison construction in the state, a
theme picked up during the luncheon address by guest speaker
Wendell Griffen, Justice of the Arkansas Court of Appeals
and Pastor at Emmanuel Baptist Church of Little Rock.
"When you send a woman to
prison who has children," Judge Griffen stated, "you are
increasing the problem exponentially." "Let's be honest.
Prevailing views on drug policy are based in denial...
focused on the dismal. Our policies are disjointed, drug
users versus the rest of us. And our thinking leads to
defeatism, using language such as "war on drugs." If you
define the war by how much drugs you're keeping out and
drugs are still coming in, you lose the war. Defeat. If you
talk about how many people you stop from using drugs and
people are still using drugs, that's defeat. Everybody's
thinking about drug policy is what hasn't work, what isn't
working, and how bad off things are.
"I would like us to think
outside the box, do some hopeful thinking about drug policy.
I would suggest that we begin thinking about drug policy
wholistically -- or holistically if you want. People have
issues about income, education, fulfillment...
"We've treated symptoms with
our policies. We've treated drug addiction with
incarceration. We haven't cured addicts.
"Hopeful thinking needs to be
redemptive. Much of our thinking has been punitive. We
empower enforcement instead of rehabilitation. Surely we
have learned by now that punitive approaches are not
working.
"Current overcrowding in our
prisons gives us the opportunity to think that maybe we
don't need to build any more prisons to house drug users.
It's not stopping anything... If prison solved the situation
we wouldn't have to keep building new ones, bigger ones, and
making people pay for them.
"I feel that as a judge I
have an obligation to tell you what works. I tell you that
longer prison sentences don't keep people from using drugs.
We can liberate ourselves from the notion that longer prison
sentences are going to solve this problem.
"We need to insist on public
policy that invests in what we want or we will get public
policy that invests in what we don't want. I we want people
to be treated and delivered from substance abuse and
addiction, then we need to invest our time and money in
those areas.
"Building prisons to solve
drug problem is like building cemeteries as an answer to
cancer."
Judge Griffen suggested a
"tithe" of the prison budget be dedicated to pro-active
programs such as youth intervention and family building.
"We've bought into a big bad lie," Judge Griffen concluded.
In describing how jobs have moved from agriculture to
industry and now to the new information age, he observed
that Arkansas needed to replace jobs that had moved
offshore. But instead of changing the educational system to
prepare people for jobs in the new information age, "we
decided to get new factories called prisons."
Now, Judge Griffen continued,
there are white communities that would never tolerate black
or brown people moving in who will pay to build prisons that
are populated with black and brown people. And this is
because running a prison provides employment to the local
white community.
Speakers also addressed the
importance of appropriate child care that stimulates
emotional bonding and mental development (Sue Martin) and
the implementation of effective interactions between
teachers, counselors and other providers for troubled kids
in elementary school (Tonya Childress). For children in teen
years, there are effective intervention materials developed
by Dr. Irene Lee at the University of Arkansas at Pine
Bluff, available through each county's cooperative extensive
service office.
Discussion included an
overview of juvenile justice processes and shortcomings
(April Rye and Juanita Jackson), and one panel was devoted
to special problems that increase risk for kids, such as
improper nutrition (Marilou Brodie), brain disorders (Joyce
Soularie), and over-reaction to teenage behavior with "zero
tolerance" policies (Rita Sklar). Of special concern are
situations where young black males are singled out for
disciplinary action at a much higher rate than young white
males, even though the offending act may be the same (Dr.
Wynona Bryant-Williams).
One panel of speakers focused
on new ideas for funding pro-active youth programs. Don
Crary of New Futures for Youth described a Little Rock
tax-based program that targets entire neighborhoods with
facilities and programs that provide opportunities for young
people to learn and contribute back to their communities.
Since the implementation of the New Futures programs, crime
rates among youth have dropped significantly.
Geoff Oelsner described
innovative intervention techniques for treating addiction
that involve advanced types of meditation and other Buddhist
methods. Denele Campbell explained that money seized in
drug arrests could provide an important new source of
funding for pro-active programs and youth substance abuse
treatment. Mike Huddleston discussed the correlation between
lack of available substance abuse treatment programs and an
increase in substance abuse.
Question and answer periods
and a concluding discussion were facilitated by Anne Murphy,
who helped participants define specific objectives for
future action, which included the creation of a resource
guide that would help parents and service providers in each
community be informed of programs and funding that are
available.
Many participants volunteered
to network on activities that would include reform of state
laws, such as alternative sentencing for nonviolent
offenders and dedicating a percentage of the criminal
justice budget to support prevention programs.
Panelists
Panel I: Focus on the
Early Years
-
Brenda Olive, formerly
incarcerated mother
-
Dee Ann Newell, M.A. Program
Coordinator, Winthrop Rockefeller Public Education
Program for Children of Incarcerated Parents, Centers
for Families and Children, P. O. Box 251970, Little Rock
AR 72225-1970;
lujo@aristotle.net; 501-666-8686.
-
Sue Martin, PhD, ECE, MSHE,
Child Development Center, P. O. Box 4106, University of
Arkansas, Fayetteville, AR 72702-4106; 501-575-4578.
- Tonya Childress, LSW,
Social Worker, Jefferson Elementary School,
Fayetteville, AR 72701; 501-444-3087.
Panel II: Focus on the
Teen Years
-
Irene Lee, PhD., Extension
Family and Child Development Specialist, University of
Arkansas at Pine Bluff, 1200 N. University Slot 4966,
Pine Bluff AR 71601; 870-543-8530.
-
Juanita Jackson, LSW,
Certified Juvenile Probation Officer, Southwest Arkansas
Counseling and Mental Health Services, P. O. Box 234,
Mineral Springs, AR 71851; 870-287-4878.
- April Rye, Attorney Ad
Litem, Washington County Juvenile Court, 41 E. Center,
Fayetteville, AR 72701; 501-444-1739.
Panel III: Special
Problems
-
Marilou Brodie, MS, RD, LD,
Pediatric Nutrition Consultant, Arkansas Department of
Health, 4815 W. Markham, Slot 23, Little Rock, AR
72205-3867;
mbrodie@healthyarkansas.com; 501-661-2914.
-
Joyce Soularie, Education
Director, National Alliance for the Mentally Ill
(NAMI-Arkansas), 712 W. 3rd, Suite 200, Little Rock AR
72201;
nami-ar@nami.org; 1-800-844-0381.
-
Rita Sklar, Executive
Director, Arkansas Chapter-ACLU, 904 W. 2nd, Suite 1,
Little Rock AR 72201; 501-374-2842.
- Dr. Wynona
Bryant-Williams, Director, Black Family Studies Program,
Philander Smith College, 812 W. 13th Street, Little Rock
72202; 501-370-5243.
Panel IV: Exploring
Solutions
-
Geoff Oelsner, LCSW,
Clinical Social Workers and founder of Buddhist
Meditation and Spiritual Support Group, 1451 Canterbury
Road, Fayetteville AR 72701; 501-521-2395.
-
Denele Campbell, Executive
Director, Drug Policy Education Group, 541 West Meadow,
Fayetteville AR 72701; 479-839-2475.
-
Don Crary, Executive
Director, New Futures for Youth, 400 W. Markham, Suite
702, Little Rock AR 72201; 501-374-1011.
- Mike Huddleston,
formerly clinical director at Youth Bridge, 1702 Dick
Smith, Springdale, AR 72764;
hud@arkansas.net;
501-521-1532.
Honored Guest, luncheon
address:
Wendell Griffen, Pastor
Emmanuel Baptist Church and Justice, Arkansas Court of
Appeals, 3323 W. 12th Street, Little Rock AR 72204;
501-666-6252.
Facilitator:
Anne Murphy, MEd, LAC, in
private practice at Sunbridge Counseling Associates, 65 E.
Sunbridge Drive, Fayetteville AR 72703; 501-443-9707. |